Parent Wars

  • Bookmark this on Hatena Bookmark
  • Hatena Bookmark - Parent Wars
  • Share on Facebook
  • Post to Google Buzz
  • Bookmark this on Yahoo Bookmark
  • Bookmark this on Livedoor Clip
  • Share on FriendFeed

“If you have the means, if you don’t have to work, then why not stay home with your kids?” comes the rat-a-tat-tat from the trenches on the west.

“You can’t judge what’s best for every parent!” echoes from the pillboxes on the hillside to the east.

“I’m sorry you don’t love your kids enough to want to spend all day with them!” lands with a concussive “boom” and takes out some of the foxholes to the north.

“If you’re such a judgmental asshole what makes you think your kids are better of with you at home with them?” shatters the brief stillness as the suicide bomber sets off his vest in the middle of the makeshift earthworks.

More artillery rattles off stone walls, upsetting rolling tanks and armoured personnel carriers bringing reinforcements in for both sides. “It’s for the good of the children!” “It’s for the good of the family!”

The bodies of the dead and dismembered rot in pools of vitriol and bitter tears. The bald vultures feast on every righteous, sanctimonious corpse, breathing in the fetid air cast off by the decomposing flesh of bodies losing their integrity in the blazing lights.

The moral of the story really should be: nobody wins except the vultures. If vultures could start wars they surely would. And maybe they do.

(Editor’s Note: I’m actually not neutral in this fight. The biggest mistake isn’t, as some think, considering all parents to be the same, and so the best choice for one is the best for all; the biggest mistake is in thinking that all children are the same, and that they all need a parent with them at all times.

I’ve seen the use of babysitters and daycare referred to as “outsourcing” parenting, with the implication being that any such situation is detrimental to the child in some way. This line is so stark there that it can’t help but be wrong. Kids require a threshold of parental involvement to be reached, surely, but I think this can be reached by the quality of attention as well as through quantity. The point is to not allow them to feel abandoned, but constantly embraced by their parents’ choices for them. Daycare, school, babysitting: these are all situations in which the child can either feel comfortable or neglected by his parents, and if he does feel so neglected then something has gone wrong. But it is thoroughly mistaken to think that these situations necessarily result in feelings of neglect. Bad parents will make their kids feel neglected and abandoned no matter where they are.)

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • “Bad parents will make their kids feel neglected and abandoned no matter where they are.” Unfortunately, this is too true.

    I am not sure what started the wars but I think your post was well thought out and very well written.
  • Man, you are one brave dude to tackle this topic. I love reading all of the comments - vested parents come in all shapes and sizes, don't we, and isn't that what our kids need? Bravo, Backpacking Dad.
  • My sister always says, "Whatever is best for YOUR family. And I try to live by that.

    But what jumped out at me was your comment, "the biggest mistake is in thinking that all children are the same, and that they all need a parent with them at all times."

    I never thought about it that way. Thanks for pushing me out of the box!
  • I was a SAHM for 12 years, until both kids were well entrenched in school. It worked for us. I went back to an office job for 4 years until being laid off recently. Because of health issues with my son, I'm not looking to return to the work world, but instead am looking into working from home. It works for us. Friends keep asking me when I'm going back to work. I am working, just not what 'they' think is work.

    You do have to do what is right for your family, and not worry about what 'they' think, or try to proselytize your decisions as being the only way .
  • Ya gotta do what is right for you. Plain and simple.
  • ali
    yes. just yes.
  • Vultures, them crooked vultures. Oh wait, that's a different reply for a different blog...

    I'm a mom and a business owner - my husband and I own the company together and the kid. We try our very best to spend as much time with Cyrus as possible. But, one of us needs to work every day. Otherwise, the poor kid will have nothing to eat and stressed out 'rents.

    We have a part time nanny and between the three of us. I'd say we 1/3 it. Some weeks I may have 2/3s, others Bryan might. It really just depends on a wide variety of things.

    Bottom line, I always want to be home with him but we need to support our family. It's a constant balance and it's working. He's such a happy guy.

    For now, the vultures will have to keep circling. Thanks so much for the post.
  • Thank you; for articulating what my heart couldn't because I was so wrapped up in feeling mad and a bit guilty. Awesome :)
  • As you already know, I was on the Dr. Phil Mommy War episode. I did not know that the topic would be SAHM vs Working Mom when I went. He was "calling all bloggers" to attend (for the publicity we would give him perhaps?). The show was aimed at the ratings war and intentionally tried to stir up controversy. I tried to be a voice of reason in the crowd, but probably did not succeed with my small part on the show. The point is ... yes, every kid is different. So is every mom, every dad, and every family. Each family has to do what works best for them. It's so much easier to do so when we all support each other instead of criticize each other's choices.

    Now ... Can't we all just get along?
  • Oops , I meant "You would have ". not "you've". Typing well would be a nice skill to have
  • Where were you when Dr. Phil thought he'd drudge up this little war again last week. You've have shut them all the hell up. And very well I might add.
  • I should have known that any commenter of Redneckmommy's would be a guy who is way smarter and funnier than I am. Have you always been that good-looking? Will you e-mail me some pics?

    Redneckmommy is a sweetheart and I'm sorry that I left that senseless comment on her blog. I was drunk, as I usually am in the afternoon, and I just don't come across very nice when I'm like that. Thankfully, my kids were taken away a long time ago because I'm really a terrible parent when I've been drinking.

    I just want to apologize totally, completely, profusely, and sincerely for any harm I've ever caused anyone with my words. I know I'm ridiculous, and that I smell terrible even after I shower. Please, can I send you some money? I'm going to catch you a delicious bass.

    Jolene
  • Thanks Jolene. I know how hard it must have been to admit to your misconduct and bad behaviour.

    No worries. I hold nothing but love in my heart for you.

    Big internet hugs to you.
  • Thanks Jolene. You're a doll. I don't care what they all say about you.
  • If you have to work to support your family I totally support you. If you can live on a single income so that a parent can stay home with the kids I think its great.
  • I never thought to equate this argument to trench warfare! :-) I'm not neutral either. Day care is outsourcing and it's terribly wrong in almost all circumstances. There, see? I fired another volley! Hmm, wonder what the retaliation will be? Hey, war is hell.
  • Helen
    In these parent wars, everyone thinks what they do is the right thing to do, that it's the very best way to do it, the only way to raise kids.

    And that's the secret: what YOU are doing is the right, best and possibly only thing for your family. And what everyone else does doesn't matter.

    Until Dr Phil gets involved.
  • Hahahahahahaha!!!! 'Touche'!!!
  • I guess I have "outsourced " my kids almost since birth ...both out of necessity and sanity (mostly necessity)...I THINK (and hope) we are all doing better for it.. Then again, choices were limited...My kids see a hard working single parent, and I hope they absorb the hard working part..... I could be one of MANY stay at home moms I know, who do little more than meet friends for lunch and go for facials, and hire tutors to help the kids scholastically, yet are not an actual participant in their child's upbringing..Not sure which one works...but so far? My kids seem to be taking the lead..And THAT? That is enough for me!
  • Oh I agree. In fact, I think our son really benefits from having babysitters (in our home) while we're at work. I totally miss him all day and I really look forward to the one day a week I stay home with him, but I love that they introduce him to new things and that he interacts with people other than us!

    As for the phrasing “outsourcing” parenting, I have to say, the closer what the babysitters are doing is to parenting, the better. We didn't hire them to sit around and watch him from afar all day and maybe jump in if he's going to hit his head or something - we hired them to interact, teach, etc. and basically be us when we can't be there!
  • Jen
    Don't take this the wrong way, but: I love you.

    (Was that weird?)
  • I was a child care provider for over 30 years. Believe me when I say that, for some children; for some families....the child is better off in a good, loving daycare.
  • I can't remember if you use curse words here, so, instead of my initial reaction I will say "Preach it, brother man!" I was going to write my own rant about this tired, we need to boost our ratings topic but yours is much more eloquent.

    Thank you for calling it "parents" rather than SAHM vs WAHM the way it's usually referred to. (Not to dismiss any of the single moms/dads out there, I'm just way over this being referred to as an issue only between moms)
  • While this is an excellent piece, I feel somewhat misled. I assumed from your tweet about the letter "argh" that there would be pirates.
  • I couldn't have said it better. What works for one make not work for another. It's the child here who's the barometer of the situation... like you said, if he's feeling abandoned and neglected, then something's definitely wrong. If, however, the balance of freedom and independence with supervision and nurturing is reached, then everyone is a winner. Because let's face it: parents need a break too.
  • babybeatnik
    "Bad parents will make their kids feel neglected and abandoned no matter where they are."

    I agree to 100% of this post but that line stood out the most.

    You say you are not neutral in this, and I feel you are right. I feel like often times it is worse to remain neutral, but perhaps moderate would be a better stance.
  • Very good point. I actually never put it into words like that, but you're right. Even my own 2 kids need different parenting; it does boil down to quality...and has nothing to do with love.
  • Been there, done that...experienced the TV Show LIVE...yea, I would like someone to spend eight hours with my ADHD/OCD child while I work. That's a whole other factor besides the fact that I have bills to pay. Southern California ain't cheap. Believe me, we want to move to cheaper ground, but alas that family thing gets in the way, every time.
  • This: "the biggest mistake is in thinking that all children are the same," is exactly how I feel; it's what I've been thinking when this shit boils up.

    Every single child is different, needs (a myriad of) different things, and you know what? None of us is perfect at knowing exactly what all of those things is for any of them. If we're trying we're succeeding at some things and failing at others. When you love your children and want the best for them... when you try to provide them with a healthy and nurturing environment (no matter what that ends up being) you are doing your job as a parent.

    I'm just so sick of anyone saying what is best for any other family, or raising their personal choices above the crowd, seeking to place them on a pedestal.
  • Bravo. Well said. I hate when vultures win.
blog comments powered by Disqus