When Parents Leave The Burn Book Out

Burn book

On one day each week, Erin’s kindergarten has an early dismissal, right around lunchtime. This is also a day I keep Adrian home from preschool, so I meet Erin at her classroom with Adrian, a lunch, and a picnic blanket, and we hang out and eat lunch next to the playground. Erin and Adrian will dash around, playing, then orbit back for some more food. Other parents are there with their own picnic blankets, their own lunches, their own children. Since the entire school lets out early, kids from many different classes end up on the playground together, and parents from many different classrooms end up on the grass.

As Erin flitted around, climbing ropes and swinging on monkey bars, I sat with Adrian on our blanket and ate lunch. Just off to my left sat a group of three moms, friends or good acquaintances, who were talking about their classroom dynamics. I wasn’t trying to pay attention, but I also wasn’t trying not to pay attention, so bits and pieces slipped by. Allow me to paraphrase:

Mom 1: “I just can’t handle some of the kids in the first grade class.”

Mom 2: “Oh, I know. Why did that classroom get stuck with all the bad ones?”

Mom 3: “Yeah, your class really did get most of them.”

Mom 1: “When the list was posted, another mom came up to me and thanked me for having one of the only two normal kids in the class.”

Mom 2: “I think it will get better. I think half of them are on Ritalin now.”

Mom 3: “We need to figure out how to get Melissa’s kid in the school. She’s on the waitlist. She’s great.”

Mom 1: “Why can’t we just kick out five or six kindergartners? Then there would be room.”

Mom 2: “Yeah.”

Mom 3: “Yeah.”

Mom 1: “Say, where are our kids?”


Mom 1: “Oh, nevermind. They’re over there, throwing sand in each other’s eyes.”

Gossip happens. Apparently it happens enough about the kids at this school, though, that someone felt the need to send out a cautionary e-mail about it a few weeks ago, reminding parents that their snapshots of children in the classroom were not fair samples, and to charitably refrain from forming snap judgments about the children with whom their precious pets would be associating.

When I received that e-mail I was a little surprised. I hadn’t been part of the school life until this year, so I had no sense of what this e-mail was about: were parents really behaving badly, or was the e-mailer hypersensitive to something? I couldn’t even tell if the e-mailer was faculty, staff, or a parent. As I said, I hadn’t been part of the school life for very long.

But apparently the e-mail was written in a spirit that has a solid foundation. I met the gossipy parents today, though “met” isn’t quite accurate. I was less perplexed by the fact of their gossip itself than I was at their brazenness. They weren’t out to coffee, or at someone’s house. They were sitting on a playground with the parents of other children who go to their school, and they were carving the world up into their good and bad camps, the normies and the Ritalin-heads, the desirables and the un-. They cared so little for who overheard them that were speaking freely in front of me. Someone who, as it turns out, is close friends with another parent with a child in the first grade; I am also the parent of a kindergartner, a member of that faceless group they so easily excised to make room for their friend’s kid.

Why do people suck so badly?

Before I fall off my high horse, I ought to admit that I’m not above gossip, or forming snap judgments of other kids. And clearly I’m not above forming snap judgments of other parents. I hope that I learned from today’s encounter though: I hope I learned to at least always be aware when I have an audience at my judge-y gossip session.

3 thoughts on “When Parents Leave The Burn Book Out”

  1. I think your story also illustrates the herd mentality where bullies evolve. the righteous attitude of these women mixed with their precious snowflakes young developing minds sounds just like a launching pad for cruelty to come.

  2. Very good point. Good reminder to watch what we say. They are, after all, only children. Thank you for posting this.

  3. I understand those parents a bit, absolutely they shouldn’t have gossiped like they did, but because my niece who is in 5th grade this year, had a class so bad last year that her teacher (a very experienced teacher I might add) was reduced to tears nearly EVERY. SINGLE. DAY, I blame the school for failing to address her concerns, and the concerns my sister raised in emails to the school, but I felt like due to disciplinary issues, my niece really had a wasted year and seems to be playing catch-up (academically) this year. I was asked to go take photographs at the school, end of the year, for the yearbook. The school told me to come during lunch and recess so I could photograph the kids without interfering with class time, I did as requested and was appalled at how my niece’s class was treated, I was in that lunch room while every class in the school came thru and no other class was as hated by staff as the one my niece was in. The lunchroom monitors made them sit boy girl (every other class was able to sit as they wished), and hovered over their tables frequently hollering at them, when they lined up to leave they were the only class forced to look at the wall while waiting in line. I left in tears and it was ONLY then my niece mentioned that she was often unable to eat her lunch because the little jerk she was forced to sit by daily thought spitting in her food was funny, and she never told because she “wasn’t a snitch”. My niece hated EVERY DAY of school last year, and while i had been quick to dismiss this as ‘she must be getting to the age where we all hated school’ i certainly cant dismiss how happy she is in school this year with a better class. Perhaps the parents were complete assholes who had no basis of complaint, or perhaps their experiences have jaded them, perhaps they have witnessed their own child suffering because of the actions of a few obnoxious kids. Sure, its life, we all remember feeling unfairly punished for the behavior of a few, but I certainly don’t remember feeling that way every day of an entire school year.

Comments are closed.